| Team | Pic | Player | Position | NFL Team |
| Animal House | | Peyton Manning | Qb | Colts |
| Asstanners | | Jake Plummer | Qb | Cardinals |
| Fantasy Takers | | Terrell Davis | Rb | Broncos |
| Ferocious Frankie Jeeters | | Brett Favre | Qb | Packers |
| Frequent Flyers | | Brad Johnson | Qb | Redskins |
| Gamma Guys | | Jerome Bettis | Rb | Steelers |
| Holliday's Huckleberry | | Edgerrin James | Rb | Colts |
| Murph & the Magictones | | Drew Bledsoe | Qb | Patriots |
| Pres.Trophy Winners | | Brian Griese | Qb | Broncos |
| Sigmund & Sea Monsters | | Eddie George | Rb | Titans |
| Smokey & the Bandit | | Joey Galloway | Wr | Cowboys |
| Vanilla Ice | | Marvin Harrison | Wr | Colts |